005.jpg
The Russian Battlefield
005.jpg
JoomlaWatch Stats 1.2.9 by Matej Koval
Главная Военный форум
Russian (CIS)English (United Kingdom)

Подписка на обновления

IREMEMBER.RU

Сейчас на сайте:
  • 20 гостей
  • 4 роботов

Посетители

Сегодня: 81
Вчера: 2572
На этой неделе: 81
На прошлой неделе: 20775
В этом месяце: 86470
В прошлом месяце: 67110
Всего: 153580



Баннер

Здравствуйте, Гость
Пожалуйста Вход или Регистрация.    Забыли пароль?

Немного о танковых таранах
(1 просматривают) (1) гость
ВнизСтр: 1
ТОПИК: Немного о танковых таранах
#746
Немного о танковых таранах 1 Год, 4 мес. назад  
** Здесь обсуждается содержание статьи: Немного о танковых таранах **

n_a

Сообщения для Гостей запрещены
 
#169
A few words on tank ramming 2 год, 4 мес. назад  
This thread discusses the Content article: A few words on tank ramming

I've been on this site for a while now and I've been looking for info on this, and now I have found some.

Cheers, I wonder what David Glandz would make of this:unsure:, a net friend of mine asked him about tank ramming in Kursk and he said that as far as he knows, it did'nt happen.

Thoughts gentlemen?

Tom
The dirty German
Soldier
Посты: 27
Оффлайн
Сообщения для Гостей запрещены
 
#553
RE: A few words on tank ramming 1 Год, 8 мес. назад  
I think that it considers that it propaganda, I do not understand why it so thinks. How to prove that tank ramming it it is real? Likely there are awards received for it and documents confirming these awards. Excuse for my English
w1tek
Soldier
Посты: 17
ОффлайнКлик для просмотра профиля
Сообщения для Гостей запрещены
 
#556
RE: A few words on tank ramming 1 Год, 8 мес. назад  
w1tek:
I think that it considers that it propaganda, I do not understand why it so thinks. How to prove that tank ramming it it is real? Likely there are awards received for it and documents confirming these awards. Excuse for my English

Any propaganda must follows some idea. What idea to propagate the tank ramming? Was it true or false it means nothing and proves nothing.
V_P
V.I.P.
Администратор
Посты: 360
ОффлайнКлик для просмотра профиля
Пол: Муж.
Редактирование: 31/05/2009 17:39 Кто - .
Сообщения для Гостей запрещены
 
#557
RE: A few words on tank ramming 1 Год, 8 мес. назад  
Yes-if it пропоганда that what purpose was at it?
w1tek
Soldier
Посты: 17
ОффлайнКлик для просмотра профиля
Сообщения для Гостей запрещены
 
#558
RE: A few words on tank ramming 1 Год, 8 мес. назад  
I don't see any propaganda reason and thus tank ramming was just another face of war, not propaganda.
V_P
V.I.P.
Администратор
Посты: 360
ОффлайнКлик для просмотра профиля
Пол: Муж.
Сообщения для Гостей запрещены
 
#559
RE: A few words on tank ramming 1 Год, 8 мес. назад  
It agree, but it seems to me that in the West think differently
w1tek
Soldier
Посты: 17
ОффлайнКлик для просмотра профиля
Сообщения для Гостей запрещены
 
#583
Re:A few words on tank ramming 1 Год, 8 мес. назад  
Hi tek, I think I understand (and thanks for the first post on this thread I was losing hope), it all came about in a WW II game that I have played a number of years. I have read some books and accounts that the Russians rammed some German tanks in the Kursk battle. And I wanted to put that in a Kursk game I was running at the time (think miniature tabletop game, 15mm range for the models). I asked opinions on it in their game site forum and in the end I got that reply from a friend of David Glandz. The other comments related to earlier in the war when some KVs ran out of ammo and had gun barrel problems so they rammed some of the German tanks, but ONLY in Early-War....

I did'nt think to much about it but I wondered why I heard so much about it, propaganda or not. I went to another site and some very good Russian members posted some books and topics they had on these tank rammings, and the article here (Alex for one).
Did Glandz maybe not look for this aspect of the battle specifically, I don't know but I think the brave Russians did in fact do this. It does'nt sem to be a common occurance and a «doctrine» to be taught and used by every tank commander. But a do or die attitude to take a German tank out regardless by some tank crews seems to ring true.

I think the Propaganda is more linked to the 1000s of tanks on each side fighting and getting knocked out in the specific area of Prokhorovka.

Thanks for the posts tek and V_P, its nice to chat with you guys.

Cheers

Tom:)
The dirty German
Soldier
Посты: 27
Оффлайн
Редактирование: 03/06/2009 04:15 Кто - .
Сообщения для Гостей запрещены
 
#585
RE: A few words on tank ramming 1 Год, 8 мес. назад  
The dirty German thanks that has come
w1tek
Soldier
Посты: 17
ОффлайнКлик для просмотра профиля
Сообщения для Гостей запрещены
 
#586
RE: A few words on tank ramming 1 Год, 8 мес. назад  
w1tek писал (а):
It agree, but it seems to me that in the West think differently

They're always afraid anything they didn't hear is a soviet propaganda
V_P
V.I.P.
Администратор
Посты: 360
ОффлайнКлик для просмотра профиля
Пол: Муж.
Сообщения для Гостей запрещены
 
#623
Re:A few words on tank ramming 1 Год, 7 мес. назад  
Yes, some do (think) just that from some sources, I try to find out if at all possible what can be learned from various sources on one topic. Then a better understanding can hopfully be achieved in the end.

Cheers, I try to look at both sides as to what may have been written down and reported on specific battles, Kursk has always interested me since I first heard about it many years ago, then later Bagration.

Tom
The dirty German
Soldier
Посты: 27
Оффлайн
Сообщения для Гостей запрещены
 
ВверхСтр: 1
Модераторы: , Panzerknacker